Standards Site

 
 

The impact of teacher-directed and child-directed pretend play on cognitive competence in kindergarten children

This digest found in

Early years

Is allowing time for pretend play in pre-schools justified?

This study showed how different types of behaviours were demonstrated in pretend play. The authors suggest these are important for academic readiness and later school success, indicating that time spent in pretend play is time well spent.

The researchers found:

  • significantly more cognitive behaviours associated with thinking, knowing and remembering emerged during group free play managed by teachers when compared with the play activities directed by teachers from the front of the class;
  • teacher-directed pretend play fostered social and emotional development more than child-directed group play;
  • under teacher direction, children's persistence and thinking behaviours gradually decreased, thereby shortening the length of the lesson, compared with the child-directed group play condition;
  • children were found to take greater pleasure in play and learning when they were free to play in groups managed by their teacher than when their play was directed by their teacher;
  • there was no significant difference in teachers' behaviour between direct teaching and group management - the number of stimuli given by the teachers was similar for both forms of class organisation; and
  • mixed-age classes had a positive effect on children's social development and thinking skills.

The authors believe their results support play-based curricula in programmes for pre-school children and pointed out the possible repercussions of giving young children little opportunity to experience pretend play. They suggest free group play (managed by teachers) supports children's later problem solving skills, social skills and academic areas, such as literacy, mathematics and science.