1. Framework home
  2. Introduction
  3. English
  4. Mathematics
  5. Science
  6. ICT
  7. Help

Evaluating

What is important about Evaluating?

This aspect of ICT is a separate strand, but in planning would be integrated with other strands and substrands. It is also explicitly referenced in some substrands.

Evaluating work in order to improve it

ICT engenders a culture of development and improvement. Since almost everything pupils do with ICT can be regarded as work under development, it is relatively easy to encourage pupils to try out different approaches to seek something better. The incentive is there to explore different options, compare a new outcome with its predecessor, and debate alternative strategies for solving a problem or creating a design. Annotating and displaying successive improvements during the development stage helps pupils to document how they have evaluated and modified their products.

Pupils should select and store evidence to show development in the content and quality of their work. The evidence might be electronic or paper notes, digital images, video and audio tape, and sequences of project files on disk, linked by a contents list. Notes should justify why ICT was used or why particular programs or options were chosen, and how these improved the work at various stages. A bank of work in progress allows pupils to refer quickly to previous approaches to inform their current work, or to return to a previous project to improve it with the benefit of hindsight.

Recognising fitness for purpose

Pupils need to understand what constitutes improvement or better fitness for purpose to develop a quality outcome. For example, a search for information on a topic may at first yield too many items of interest. By clarifying what they are looking for, and using ICT judiciously, pupils can focus on the most relevant items. Evaluation of the retrieved information and creation of sharper criteria for focusing the search lead to further trials and refinement, or even to different approaches to the search.

You can help pupils appreciate the importance of fitness for purpose by giving them regular examples of how ICT is used in school and beyond. Encourage them to consider the advantages and disadvantages of different ways of searching, analysing and reporting information for particular purposes, or of communicating with a remote audience. Pupils need to understand why and when tools such as spreadsheets and techniques such as graphical representation are useful.

Recognising inappropriate uses of ICT

As pupils gain familiarity with a greater variety of tools and techniques, you need to help them recognise when and when not to use ICT facilities to perform certain tasks. For example, pupils need to appreciate the advantages and disadvantages of using props such as wizards in their work and to recognise when it would be appropriate to design their own automated procedures. Make sure pupils are aware of uses of ICT that are feasible but inappropriate, for example:

  • using an electronic calculator when a calculation should be done mentally
  • generating inappropriate graphs of data, merely because a facility exists; for example, using a line graph to display discrete data that should be presented in a bar chart or pie chart
  • labouring to input one page of text and figures that could have been handwritten and photocopied, if necessary
  • using ICT for a piece of work that is not enhanced sufficiently by that use, or for work that is not saved electronically
  • copying passages from CD-ROM or the internet for reproduction in an essay, without having a strategy for selecting and summarising suitable parts
  • spending more time on minor, repetitive embellishments to a document than on content or a consideration of audience
  • logging data in an experiment, with little consideration of the volume of data that is needed and the effects of the rate of sampling
  • using technically-complex ICT facilities to produce material for an audience that does not have access to the facilities required – for example, the latest version of browser software.

Checking outcomes

Another aspect of developing pupils' ability to improve their work is to make sure that, whenever they use electronic devices or software to represent, measure or process data, they check regularly that:

  • the tool they are using measures or manages the material exactly as intended
  • they use suitable ICT tools – for example, print preview and a spellchecker – to support the improvement of their work.

You should teach pupils to be sensitive to errors when they are working with ICT including calculators, digital meters and scales. For example, encourage pupils regularly to:

  • check that they are working on the right version of a document
  • preview material before printing it
  • make mental checks of the accuracy of calculations
  • when adding a new cell to the end of a spreadsheet row or column, check that its content is included in the total of the row or column
  • save or record work after a useful result has been obtained; for example, after incorporating a good idea or checking a numerical result
  • check that digital meters are calibrated and yield sensible readings.

Evaluating has one substrand in the ICT Framework, which is:

4.1 Evaluating work.